Welcome to Mainstay Insurance

Auto, Home, Life, Health and Commercial Insurance

About Us

Protect your Family

It's our goal to provide you and your family protection in your lives, We Offer: Home Insurance, Auto Insurance, LIfe and Health Insurance.

Protect Your Business

Running your business is what you should be worrying about. We take care of protecting your investment. Contact us for all your Commercial Insurance needs!


We are Committed to being there when you need us! Please Contact Lorie Reinert, Megan Novotny or Mike Sand to discuss protecting you and your family.  

Finding the Right fit for you!

Progressive, AAA, Nationwide, Travelers, Liberty Insurance, Safeco, State Auto, Westbend, Hartford, Kemper and many more to meet your needs!

Contact Us

Better yet, see us in person!

We love our customers, so feel free to visit during normal business hours.

Mainstay Insurance

235 East Cedar Street, St. Joseph MN 56374



Monday - Friday: 9am - 5pm

Saturday: By appointment

Sunday: Closed

Email us for a quote!